Friday, April 25, 2025

Courts of the Old West

By Jennifer Uhlarik 

If you’re anything like me, watching western movies as a kid led to the belief that the western territories and states were a completely lawless land. Sure, I knew there were lawmen—sheriffs, marshals, and the like—and even a plethora of bounty hunters. Western movies, shows, and books were filled with those. But so many westerns, whether on the big or small screen, or in print, conveyed the idea that things were dealt with by vigilante justice rather than in an actual court of law. People took matters in their own hands, rather than seeking out a lawyer, a judge, or a court, right? Turns out, nothing was further from the truth.

 

In researching for my newest release, Love and Order: A Three-Part Old West Romantic Mystery, I had the pleasure of ferreting out whether there was the court system in Colorado Territory in the 1800s and how such an animal might have operated in that time and place. 


Judge Roy Bean, a Justice of the Peace, dubbed himself the "Only law west of the Pecos."

So, the court system in the western territories was typically set up with a Territorial Supreme Court, comprised of three justices who were each appointed by the President of the United States. These justices were not only the highest judges in the territory—but often, they were the only judges. (Yes, there might have been Justices of the Peace who were in charge of hearing small local matters, but these JP’s were not typically part of the Territorial Court system that would try cases dealing with the Territorial laws. An example would be Judge Roy Bean).

 

Each territory was segmented into three parts, and each Supreme Court Justice became the traveling judge who oversaw cases in one of those territorial districts. Each judge had a U.S. Marshal working closely with him to schedule trials, who acted as bailiff during trials, and helped with other court matters. If a lawman or prosecutor wished to bring a case to trial, he would contact the Marshal, get the case on the judge’s docket, and then would have to wait until the judge and his traveling court continent made it through the circuit to the nearest town to hear that case.

 

In most places, there wasn’t a dedicated courthouse in which to host a trial. So where did the proceedings happen? Anywhere they could find a place. Court cases might have been held in an open field if the weather permitted, in a schoolhouse, a church, a meeting hall, or a saloon. And the cases were often seen as a great source of entertainment, so people would often take off work to witness the spectacle. And a spectacle it often was! 


An Old West Saloon


Though the judges had garnered the attention of the President to receive the appointment as territorial justice, many of them saw this as a punishment. They viewed it not as an honor, but as being banished to the uncivilized territories. Thus, many of them took a very lackadaisical attitude toward their jobs. Judges were sometimes known to come into court drunk (or to become so as the day went on—especially when the venue was a saloon). They also often lent only half an ear to the proceedings while they trimmed their nails or took care of other personal grooming tasks. And often, lots of shenanigans went on because the judge would allow the audience too much power. For instance, in one case I read about, held in a local saloon, many of the townsfolk who were in attendance would holler out, asking for a recess, so that they could get a refill on their alcoholic beverages—and the judge permitted it. I’m sure you can imagine the wild and wooly spectacle such a trial might have been.

 

Certainly, some of the judges would’ve taken their jobs seriously, but many didn’t treat it with the respect it deserved. So if the outcome of a trial was in question, the defendants and their attorneys could always ask for an appeal to the Supreme Court. But wait…! Keep in mind that the judge who just heard the case was one of the three Justices of the Territorial Supreme Court, and an appeal required two of the three Justices to agree to hear the case. If the original judge ruled no (which they often did), and he could convince a second Justice to deny the request, then the appeal would go nowhere. The initial judgment stood.

 

I mentioned earlier about the court contingent that the judges traveled with. Interestingly, each territorial judge had a whole group of people they would bring along on their circuit—a slate of prosecutors, defense attorneys, a court reporter, investigators, and more. Everyone the judge would need to try a case was in that company, except for the defendants and witnesses. Now, that’s not to say that every trial lawyer traveled with the judge around the territory. In fact, one of the many interesting facts I discovered through my research was that the topmost profession in the 1800s western territories was that of attorney. So not all attorneys could travel with the itinerant court system. In fact, attorneys were so prevalent in that day that most of them had to have a second job to pay the bills, which tied many of them to their local towns. They might also own a saloon (great if the court used their venue for its cases!), ran cattle or horses on a ranch, or operated a local store. Some were miners, land surveyors, or had some other kind of business to help make ends meet. Really, the only attorneys who made a living from their law practice were the ones who were part of the traveling court system. 


By Jonathunder -
Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0,
https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=3899115

 

So if a defendant didn’t have a private attorney, a traveling defense attorney would be assigned his case. Same with the prosecutors. If a local prosecutor wasn’t bringing the case, a traveling one was assigned. These attorneys could prepare for their cases before arriving in the town where the trail was to take place by writing letters, sending telegrams, reading up on any reports or testimony that had been gathered (if there was any), and could break away from the traveling company to go and meet with a defendant or other witnesses in between other cases they were assigned. But I’m sure you can imagine, expecting a traveling attorney to mount an airtight defense under such circumstances could be a risky thing. So it was in the defendant’s interest to retain his own attorney so that he could expect a better defense. (Surprise, surprise…not a lot has changed in that aspect between the courts of old and courts of today).

 

(If you’re interested in learning more about how one became an attorney in the Old West, I wrote a post on the topic several years ago. Please find it here.)

 

Lastly, as I mentioned earlier, when the court rolled into town, it was usually quite a spectacle. Often, there was as much excitement for the court proceedings as there might be for a traveling circus, medicine show, or other form of entertainment. And sometimes, there’d be some very interesting happenings in the proceedings. In one case I read about, a widow sat quietly through the trial of her husband’s killer, waited for the verdict, and then calmly left her seat, approached the defendant, and feet from the judge, leveled her dead husband’s pistol at the killer’s belly. If my memory serves, not only the U.S. Marshal bailiff drew down on her, but so did the judge, the defense attorney, and several who’d come to watch the proceedings.

 

So yes, there was a court system in the western territories of the 1800s. But I should add one other fact. The movies, TV shows, and novels I took in during my teens did have it partially right. Because the traveling courts could take months to reach a town and try a case, it often did lead to the prevalence of vigilante groups bringing justice outside of the courts—especially since jails of the Old West tended to be rather “leaky.” (That’s a tease for next month’s topic…)

 

It's Your Turn:

Were you aware that there was a robust court system in the western territories of the 1800s? What did you find surprising about how these courts operated?

 


Jennifer Uhlarik
 discovered western novels at twelve when she swiped the only “horse” book from her brother’s bookshelf. Across the next decade, she devoured westerns and fell in love with the genre. While attaining a B.A. in writing from the University of Tampa, she began penning her own story of the Old West. She has finaled in and won numerous writing competitions and appeared on various best-seller lists. Besides writing, she’s been a business owner, a schoolteacher, a marketing director, a historical researcher, a publisher, and a full-time homemaker. She lives near Tampa, Florida, with her husband and fur children.

 

 

Available now

 

Love and Order

 

Wanted: 

Family, Love, and Justice

One Old West Mystery Solved Throughout Three Short Romantic Stories


Separated as children when they were adopted out to different families from an orphan train, the Braddock siblings have each grown up and taken on various jobs within law enforcement and criminal justice.

 

Youngest child, Callie, has pushed past her insecurities to pursue a career as a Pinkerton agent. Middle child, Andi, has spent years studying law under her adoptive father’s tutelage. And the eldest and only son, Rion, is a rough-and-tumble bounty hunter. 

 

When the hunt for a serial killer with a long history of murders reunites the brother and sisters in Cambria Springs, Colorado, they find themselves not only in a fight for justice, but also a fight to keep their newly reunited family intact. How will they navigate these challenges when further complicated by unexpected romances?

 

Thursday, April 24, 2025

The War Brides, Part 4: Jean Chartrand

By Terrie Todd

English War Bride Jean Chartrand said goodbye to her Canadian husband Wilfred in January 1946, when his unit was shipped back to Canada. Shortly afterward, Jean discovered she was pregnant, which only delayed her own departure. Though she didn’t know it then, it would take an entire year before she could join Wilfred in Oak Point, Manitoba.

Nottingham, England in 1946 Photo from Nottingham Facebook page

After the birth of her son Garry, Jean awaited word. As Christmas approached, she assumed she and her baby would be celebrating with her parents in Nottingham. Suddenly, on December 4, she received word that she would be sailing on December 9 and would have to take the train to London on the eighth. Although she’d been packing odds and ends into trunks for months, it was a scramble to pull everything together for her departure and fill out all the necessary forms. She and the other war brides stayed at the YWCA in London overnight, then boarded the train for Liverpool. She could have taken the train from Nottingham to Liverpool in less than half the time, but procedures had to be followed. (A look at the map below will show you how ridiculous that trip was.)

Map from Google Maps

The morning their ship was to dock in Halifax, the war brides awoke to a snowstorm. They were not allowed to disembark until the troops onboard went. Having been told that the brides would become Canadian citizens as soon as they stepped onto the docks—and determined to be first—Joan ran down the gangplank. On the deck, a burly military officer ordered her back onto the ship. When they could finally get off, the women found their trunks in a huge shed. Red Cross workers gave them hot drinks and cookies, plus clothing and other supplies for their children. They were given an opportunity to exchange their pounds sterling for Canadian currency before boarding trains to complete their journeys.

When they reached Montreal, the brides were told to go to the dining car for their evening meal while a Red Cross nurse cared for their children. The women welcomed the break. Unfortunately, the railroad chose that time to split the train cars between those going on to Toronto and those going to Winnipeg. You can imagine the chaos when the mothers discovered their dining car sat a mile away from the car on which their children remained. It took about an hour to reconnect mothers with children, but not without a lot of squalling, squawking, and distress.

When she arrived in Winnipeg, Jean could not find Wilf. She’d rarely seen him out of uniform. When a smiling man approached in a blue parka, relief flooded her to realize it was her husband. At long last!

Winnipeg's Union Station - courtesy Historical Winnipeg Facebook page

At her new home in Oak Point, Jean met her mother-in-law who spoke mostly French. Jean’s French was rusty, but she brushed up. Her first Christmas brought deep loneliness for home and family. She recalls showing up to a community event wearing a kilt, sweater, tweed jacket, knee socks, and brogues. She was freezing! By her second winter, she knew to wear ski pants, a doeskin shirt, parka, and snow boots. Electricity would not arrive in Oak Point for three more years.

Years later, Jean was able to join a War Brides Association, where members could reminisce, share their experiences, and laugh about the many faux pas they made when first introduced to their new country.

Sources:

Promise You’ll Take Care of My Daughter: The Remarkable War Brides of World War II, by Ben Wicks, Stoddart Publishing, Toronto 1993

Rural Electrification, Manitoba Historical Society Archives, https://www.mhs.mb.ca/


Orphaned and adopted as a toddler in 1922, Lilly Sampson pursues a nursing career in hopes it will redeem the shameful crime of arson she committed as a child. When her self-sabotaging choices only build the ash heap higher, Lilly prepares to sacrifice everything for the sake of a child she tried to abort. Can Lilly reconcile with the one person who shares all her secrets and find the strength to raise a son with special needs?

2019: While unraveling a mysterious link in her ancestry, 36-year-old Diana DeWitt is fear-stricken by the two most staggering invitations of her life: to adopt a teenager’s baby, and to marry her best friend. Will the truth Diana uncovers about her Grandmother Lilly release the grip of rejection and free her to embrace a life she only dreamed of?

Lilly’s Promise received the 2023 Best Fiction Book of the Year Award from The Word Guild.

 

Terrie Todd’s novels are set mostly in Manitoba, Canada where she lives with her husband, Jon, in Portage la Prairie. They have three adult children and five grandsons. Her next novel, Even If I Perish, releases in November 2025.

Follow Terrie here:

Blog

Facebook

Quarterly Newsletter Sign-up

Wednesday, April 23, 2025

OH, SNAP!


By Mary Davis

What do Johann Peter Spieth, Heribert Bauer, Albert-Pierre Raymond, and one of the oldest operational companies in the world have in common?

 

They each had a hand in inventing or improving the modern snap fastener.

 

A two-part fastener can be traced back to German brass-worker Johann Peter Spieth in the early 1800s. He created a unique way of attaching a button to fabric, laying the foundation for the modern snap.

 

In 1865, French industrialist Albert-Pierre Raymond, along with two other men, opened a workshop to manufacture snap fasteners to replace traditional glove buttons which were not practical.

 

Later, German inventor Heribert Bauer patented the snap (a.k.a. press stud) on March 5, 1885. It consisted of two parts that were sewn onto fabric and each had a spring mechanism. It was designed as a novelty closure for men’s trousers, and according to the patent, they were meant to make the opening and closing of men’s overalls easier. The problem was that the quick-release fastener tended to rust quickly, which could cause them to come undone at inopportune times. Even so, they were quite popular because of their ease of use.

 

Since Albert-Pierre Raymond had been making snaps for twenty years, he realized he should get a patent as well. So, a year after Bauer’s patent, Albert-Pierre Raymond filed his patent in France on May 29, 1886 and also filed patents in the U.S. and Japan. He apparently didn’t want someone else to beat him to the punch.

But it wasn’t until Hans Friedrich of the Prym company (one of the oldest operational companies in the world) improved the design with a double S-spring, that the snap really took off. The two parts held together much better than its predecessors and, with a different metal, it didn’t rust. The snap fastener was marketed under the brand name “Prym” in 1903.

 

Myra Juliet Farrell improved the snap once more by inventing a no-sew snap. Hers was a four-piece construction with prongs that stuck through the fabric.

 

Because of the ease of use, the military incorporated them into their gear. Likewise, rodeo cowboys adopted the press stud in the 1930s for safety reasons. If the cowboy fell and his shirt got caught on the saddle, the snaps would easily come undone and protect the wearer from further injury and the shirt from being torn.

 

Today, snaps come in all sorts of fun shapes, sizes, and colors.

 
SMALL TOWN ROMANCES: Inspirational Boxed Set
5 Novels by 5 bestselling, award-winning authors. You'll love these unique stories of love! Something for everyone with 2 historical, 2 contemporary, and a fantasy romance.
Get it HERE!

The Daughter’s Predicament by Mary Davis—As Isabelle Atwood’s romance prospects are turning in her favor, a family scandal derails her dreams. Despite gaining the attention of a handsome rancher, her parents are pressuring her to marry a man of their choosing to rescue her sister’s reputation. While a third suitor waits silently in the wings, hoping to sweep her off her feet. Whom will Isabelle choose?
Plus 4 others!

MARY DAVIS, bestselling, award-winning novelist, has over thirty titles in both historical and contemporary themes. Her latest release is THE LADY’S MISSION. Her other novels include THE DÉBUTANTE'S SECRET (Quilting Circle Book 4) THE DAMSEL’S INTENT (The Quilting Circle Book 3) is a SELAH Award Winner. Some of her other recent titles include; THE WIDOW'S PLIGHT, THE DAUGHTER'S PREDICAMENT, “Zola’s Cross-Country Adventure” in The MISSAdventure Brides Collection, Prodigal Daughters Amish series, "Holly and Ivy" in A Bouquet of Brides Collection, and "Bygones" in Thimbles and Threads. She is a member of ACFW and active in critique groups.

Mary lives in the Rockies and her dog, Shelby. She has three adult children and three incredibly adorable grandchildren. Find her online at:
Books2Read Newsletter Blog FB FB Readers Group Amazon GoodReads BookBub



Sources

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snap_fastener

https://www.daidalos.blog/en/journey-through-time/artikel/the-press-stud/

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prym

https://thethriftystitcher.co.uk/a-brief-history-of-the-snap-fastener/

https://blog.albastakionline.com/buttons/the-history-of-the-button-snap-from-invention-to-everyday-use/

https://www.heddels.com/2023/09/a-history-of-snap-buttons/